Friday, 16 November 2018

London Zoo’s Aquarium: The End

The news came in an email to Fellows: announcement of the inevitable end—after 96 years—of London Zoo’s Aquarium. Opened in 1924, it was then state of the art but for decades now it has been realised that the aquarium had reached the end of its useful life. It has been ‘refreshed’ a number of times, sometimes cosmetically—the entrance for example—sometimes structurally. The original large tanks were made of slate which sometimes split to spectacular and dangerous effect. Their concrete replacements were slowly affected by movement of the ground. The huge storage and filtration system for sea water (bought by ship and road tanker) has aged and better systems are now used. Forty years ago or more, Gwynne Vevers, Curator of the Aquarium (among the many jobs he did at the Zoo) told me the Aquarium needed to be replaced.

Edward George Boulenger (1888-1946) then Curator of Reptiles, prepared the outline plan after visits to large aquaria in continental Europe and became Director of the Aquarium when it was finished. John James Joass was the architect, as he was for the Mappin Terraces. The engineering of the water circulation, filtration and electrical systems was the key to success and was undertaken by Alexander Gibb and Partners. There was no plastic then and the piping for the sea water system was lined with glass since copper is lethal to marine invertebrates.

The Society failed to raise enough money to build a new Aquarium outside the Zoo but in London, while the commercial large aquarium opened in the old County Hall and in an ideal spot to attract tourists. I see the plan is now to have some sort of coral reef exhibit in the relatively new insect house and a freshwater exhibit at Whipsnade.

Even when the Aquarium was new there were others, around the coast of Britain attracting visitors However, the number of large public aquaria worldwide, most in the private sector, has led traditional zoos unable to compete. Huge heavily stocked tanks and underwater tunnels have been, and are, the order of the day for exhibition purposes, even if unsuitable for many of the inhabitants.

For those readers who have never been to London Zoo, the Aquarium was incorporated into the bottom of the Mappin Terraces, a naturalistic Hagenbeck-inspired, artificial rock edifice that rises 21 metres above Regent’s Park. When the Mappins were built in 1913-14, space was left for an aquarium underneath. Unable to proceed with the work because of the First World War, construction of the aquarium had to be delayed until the 1920s.

The whole arrangement of storage tanks high under the peaks of the Mappins, filtration system and access to the tanks for servicing was all very cleverly arranged. The only signs of the overlying structure are the wide columns in the public area. There are three halls within the structure; one freshwater; one sea water and one tropical. extending curvilinearly for 136 metres. A corner tank in the tropical hall once housed a manatee.

The famous diagram of the Aquarium showing how it fits beneath the Mappin Terraces

In the 1950s the Aquarium was often quiet with few visitors. This is because there was a charge to enter; the zoo ticket did not include access to the Aquarium. The public space was very dark and even the light from the tanks did not reach all corners. When considering the future of the Aquarium in the early 1990s I was told there were those who visited the Aquarium for activities other than making the acquaintance of its non-human inhabitants.

The type of animal accommodation provided on the lower and middle ranges of the Mappin Terraces (for bears, for example) have long been out of favour. The structure, like so many of the obsolete buildings are Grade II listed and efforts have been made to give it some use in housing animals. It is not generally realised that the concrete structure is a skin formed on wire-netting held in place and stretched between reinforced concrete framework. Erosion of the skin, particularly on the peaks, has needed costly repairs. Now, with the Aquarium gone, the Zoo has a considerable problem on its hands, one that has recurred since the 1980s—what to do with Mappins, underneath as well as on top.

I took this photograph of the Mappin Terraces in 1958


Guillery P. 1993. The Buildings of London Zoo. London: Royal Commission on the Historical Monuments of England.

Vevers HG. 1976. Management of a public aquarium. Symposia of the Zoological Society of London 40, 105-108.

Monday, 12 November 2018

Hong Kong Rodents: Huang’s Rat or Niviventer is back on the list

In my post of 2 May 2013, I considered what had happened to the name of a beautiful species of rat that occurs in Hong Kong. For decades it was known as Huang’s Rat, Rattus huang but it came to be lumped into what was Rattus fulvescens and is now Niviventer fulvescens.

The genus Niviventer was erected by Joe Truesdell Marshall (1918-205) for a group of Asian rodents previously included in Rattus. They can be distinguished by their white belly (niveus—snowy white in Latin).

Generous to a fault, I bought my wife a copy of a volume in that remarkable series The Handbook of Mammals of the World. It is the volume, Rodents II, which covers, as superbly as ever, with information up-to-date at the time of going to press, rats and mice. Having been granted access I found that Niviventer huang has been resurrected as a result of phylogenetic research in China and has been given the common name of South China White-bellied Rat.

As has been said many times, the rats and mice of China are confusing to say the least. Researchers find that specimens have been wrongly identified in museums throughout the world and one only has to look at maps of where specimens have been collected from to realise that whole regions have been missed.

Modern phylogenetics are way above my pay grade and I am not entirely sympathetic to drawing conclusions on whether a species thus defined constitutes a ‘good’ biological species reproductively isolated (or with very limited gene flow) from its near relative. I have looked up the references given in the Handbook. The main work seems to have been done with two genes, one mitochondrial and one nuclear on, in some cases, very small samples. Whether that number of genes and that number of individual samples, together with the statistical methods used, would satisfy all phylogeneticists I do not know. The authors, most of whom are based in Beijing, do make the point that more work is needed on N. huang since, on their reckoning, it may comprise more than one species.

More recently than the press date of the book, another group, based in Kunming, also examined niviventers using one mitochondrial and three nuclear genes. They found less strong evidence for the existence of N. huang as a species separate from N. fulvescens. 

Are there any morphological differences between the two species? The Beijing group found that N. huang could be differentiated from N. fulvescens by head and body length.


I have combined the maps in the Handbook to show the
current views on the distribution of the two species


Clearly, much more work with an extensive sampling of niviventers right across the distribution of these two and other species in China is needed but for the time being at least Huang’s Rat or Niviventer is back on the list of Hong Kong mammals, while N. fulvescens is out.

The only recent photograph I have been able to find of Niviventer huang
is this one from a website in Russian which Google Translate says in the
Russian-Vietnamese Research and Technology Centre


Wilson DE, Lacher TE, Mittermeier RA (editors). 2017. Handbook of Mammals of the World. Volume 7. Rodents II. Barcelona: Lynx Edicions.

Lu L, Ge D, Chesters D, Ho SYW, Ma Y, Li G, Wen Z, Wu Y, Wang J, Xia L, Liu J, Guo T, Zhang X, Zhu C, Yang Q, Liu Q. 2015. Molecular phylogeny and the underestimated species diversity of the endemic white-bellied rat (Rodentia: Muridae: Niviventer) in Southeast Asia and China. Zoologica Scripta 44 475-494. doi:10.1111/zsc.12117 

Zhang B, He K, Wan T, Chen P, Sun G, Liu S, Nguyen TS, Lin L, Jiang X. 2016. Multi-locus phylogeny using topotype specimens sheds light on the systematics of Niviventer (Rodentia, Muridae) in China. BMC Evolutionary Biology16, 261-272. doi 10.1186/s12862-016-0832-8 


Friday, 9 November 2018

Sea snakes and burrowing eels

Sea snakes are fascinating animals. There were a number of dead ones pickled in jars in the old Northcote Science Building of the University of Hong Kong. They had been gathered from the nets of the fishing fleet or the fishery research vessels. It was difficult to make out the form and original coloration of the pickled specimens. The most interesting, of which there were photographs, was one with a tiny head, thin neck but wider body. I now realise it was the Slender Sea Snake, Hydrophis, now Microcephalophis, gracilis, and could well have been the same preserved specimen used as an illustration in Hong Kong Amphibians and Reptiles. The timing is right since it was the only specimen caught in Hong Kong waters—in 1963 in Deep Bay.

The preserved specimen of the Slender Sea Snake used in
Hong Kong Reptiles and Amphibians. I have added the
red ellipse to show the very small head and thin neck

But why the small head and thin neck in many species of sea snake? The old idea, which turned out to be a ‘just-so’ story, was included on the short section on sea snakes (there was not a single photograph) in Schmidt & Inger’s 1957 book, Living Reptiles of the World:

It is remarkable that some of the longest of the sea snakes have a small head and slender neck and anterior half of the body, with a bulky abdominal portion that is very much larger in diameter. This curious body form, which recalls that of the extinct marine plesiosaurs, seems to be associated with the mechanical requirements for striking at prey in the water. Without any fixed fulcrum from which to launch its stroke, the free-swimming venomous snake makes use of the inertia of the heavy abdomen, while the great resistance of the water is made less by the slenderness of the head and neck…

Later, Harold and Helen Voris of the Field Museum in Chicago examined data on what species of fish the various sea snakes prey. They found that a large number of species eat eels. Subsequently it was found that the snakes with a small head feed on burrowing eels and gobies, and those with a very small head feed virtually exclusively on burrowing eels. Divers have also reported seeing some species of sea snake with their heads in a burrow. Therefore, it has become clear that the small-head-thin-neck type of sea snake is adapted to entering the long burrows of eels and emerging with a meal.

Along with their various physiological adaptations to life at sea, which I will not go into further here,  and the specialized feeding habits—including species which feed exclusively on fish eggs—a significant feature of sea snakes is the number of species within a relatively small geographical area. A recent paper* relates feeding on burrowing eels to the rapid increase in the number of species. The pursuit of a previously untapped food source has been well established in other animals as a trait that would be favourably selected and, therefore, act as a driver of speciation.




From*. I have added a red ellipse to highlight the differences in the width of the head and neck

There are more than 60 species of sea snake. A rapid speciation, accounting for 60% of known species—the fastest known amongst reptiles—occurred from about 7.5 million years ago. The change in body form associated with feeding on burrowing eels appears to have occurred in six or seven of the lineages determined by genomic analysis. In other words, there is strong evidence of convergent evolution.

The authors conclude:

Our study has revealed that trophic specialization has had a strong influence on body morphology in sea snakes, and this relationship is predominantly driven by the convergent evolution of microcephalic burrowing eel specialists. Dietary specialization appears to invoke strong selective pressures that manifest as predictable and rapid morphological changes. Future studies are needed to examine the genetic and developmental mechanisms underlying these dramatic body shape changes and address their role in speciation. 

Then I started to think about implications for how the small-headed sea snakes feed. Let’s assume the diameter of the neck equals the diameter of the eel’s burrow. If the snake swallows the eel (the diameter of the burrow) while in the burrow its neck will be twice the diameter of the burrow and it could get stuck. Therefore, is it perhaps more likely that the snake pulls the eel out of the burrow before swallowing it? But, if alive, the eel would stand a chance of escaping, so is that why the venom of these sea snakes is so powerful? To ensure that the eel is dead before being pulled from its burrow and to enable a quick kill by a snake that must swim to the surface in order to breathe? Alternatively, perhaps the snake only enters burrows that are wider than its neck. Then it could, perhaps ingest its prey without getting stuck. But a large eel in a large hole might then be too big to be swallowed by the small head (the maximum width of prey has been found to 1.5 times that of the neck)? Divers or remote cameras watching how these small-headed sea snakes feed may be the only ways of providing an answer.

The dangers of a snake swallowing its prey with its neck in a confined space was brought home to us on Boxing Day 1966 in Hong Kong. We were walking along Conduit Path a short distance from the top of University Drive when we found a dead rat snake with its head in a small hole in the bank. A good pull was needed to extract the snake. It was in process of swallowing a toad and the swollen throat had jammed the snake plus toad in the entrance to the hole. We could only assume that the oxygen within the small hole had run out and the snake had asphyxiated itself as it tried to retreat. Unwisely, with hindsight, we left the snake plus toad on the bank of earth, intending to pick it up on the way back from our walk and preserve it in the lab. But it had gone; some scavenger had made off with it.

*Sherratt E, Rasmussen AR, Sanders KL. 2018. Trophic specialization drives morphological evolution in sea snakes. Royal Society Open Science 5, 172141. http://dx.doi.org/10.1098/rsos.172141 

Karsen SJ, Lau M W-N, Bogadek A. 1998. Hong Kong Amphibians and Reptiles. Second Edition. Hong Kong: Provisional Urban Council.

Peaker M, Peaker SJ. 1968. Death of a snake while swallowing prey. British Journal of Herpetology 4, 38-39. 

Schmidt KP, Inger RF. 1957. Living Reptiles of the World. London: Hamish Hamilton.

Voris HK, Voris HH. 1983. Feeding strategies in marine snakes: an analysis of evolutionary, morphological, behavioral and ecological relationships. American Zoologist 23, 411-425.


Sunday, 4 November 2018

Joan Procter. Her Reptile House at London Zoo and Reptilian Thermoregulation

It is only when one reads the detail of Joan Procter’s Reptile House at London Zoo that one realises she was decades ahead of her time in terms of knowledge of the thermal requirements of reptiles. The Reptile House opened in June 1927. Apart from its ‘aquarium-principle’ lighting, crowd circulation and safe-handling area for venomous snakes, the spectra of both natural and artificial lighting were specified while additional heat was supplied to different places of the cages thus creating a temperature gradient which allowed the animals to bask and raise their body temperature above that of their surroundings.

In Joan Procter’s own words when describing how the Komodo Dragons were housed and how they had lived in the new Reptile House for 18 months:

They live in a large enclosure of natural shingle and soil, planted with living palm-trees, and provided with a cave, rocks, and a swimming-pool. A great deal of care has been exercised to provide proper climatic conditions. The roof is of Vita-glass, transparent to ultra-violet light, and Vita-lamps for artificial sunlight are installed together with two large flood-light lamps. Dull-heat radiators of the beam type are also fixed, and all this apparatus, which is invisible to the public. is protected by massive steel bars. Further, the rocks themselves are electrically heated with a type of black-heat radiator let into the actual rock, and controlled, together with the air-heaters by a thermostat, which in turn is governed by a fool-proof warning system. The light and heat are chiefly focussed on a large rock in the centre of the enclosure, and, as the dragons immediately discovered this, they are usually to be seen sunning themselves upon it.

Those who know anything about reptiles will recognise this as a throughly modern way of keeping lizards. As I pointed out in a previous article the Vita glass was to let ultraviolet rays in sunlight reach the animals. Her ‘Vita-lamps’ were actually ultraviolet-emitting lamps with Vita glass filters to block just the very short wavelengths which experiments had determined were deleterious.

Previously, reptiles kept in temperate climates were kept in accommodation heated to the temperature of a tropical shade environment. Most had no opportunity to bask and raise their temperature above the ambient. The science of thermoregulation in reptiles really only took off in the 1940s and the concepts like ‘preferred body temperature’ and  ‘behavioural thermoregulation’ developed. Thus while reptiles are indeed cold-blooded they were found able to maintain body temperatures above that of their surroundings during the hours of daylight by shuttling between the heat of the sun and the relative cool of the shade. Komodo Dragons have been shown, comparatively recently, to follow that pattern.

The preferred body temperature was later shown to be that which is optimal for biochemical processes within the body. Reptiles not allowed to achieve their preferred body temperature, even though kept in warm ‘tropical’ daytime air temperatures, were function sub-optimally. It is not surprising that such animals are lethargic, their immune system left unable to cope with infection and infestation, do not breed—and do not survive for very long. Reptiles, particularly larger ones, take a long time to die.

Joan Procter was aware that she had designed accommodation for Komodo Dragons that was superior to that elsewhere. She quoted from William Douglas Burden’s book Dragon Lizards of Komodo (see my article on the Burden expedition to Komodo here):

     …We hear of specimens taken to New York* that “it was painful to see the broken spirited beasts that barely had strength to drag themselves from one end of their cage to the other.”     ‘’"SureIy it is not all a matter of diet and change of climate... Perhaps…Varanus komodoensis, in order to survive, demands the freedom of his rugged mountains.” ...,but our specimens are perfectly happy in captivity, are attached to their keepers and their friends, and are putting on a great deal of weight.

I think we can take that as London 2: New York 0, 1928 style.

This photograph of a small boy and a Komodo Dragon may have been
taken in the original accommodation in the Reptile House in London
Zoo in 1932. Joan Procter and the keepers always seemed keen
to demonstrate how tame the Dragons had become

The heating and lighting equipment was not ‘off the shelf’. The General Electric Company Ltd (not to be confused with the American company of the same name) had research and development labs at Wembley. The Times (15 June 1927) in describing the new house reported:

The very elaborate electrical installation devised by the Research Department of the General Electric Company to meet the special requirements forms an achievement in electrical installation which is unique, and cannot be described in detail here. It may be said, however, that the installation has approximately 20 miles of electric cable for the heating system and 12 miles for the indicators and tell-tales, and that some of the compartments have up to 200 electrical connexions. The wiring for lighting is almost equally elaborate.

Miss Procter wanted material for the walls that could be cleaned. She therefore had the theatrical scenic artist, John Bull, use car enamel that would be resistant to scrubbing. I cannot find a photograph of any of the scenes painted on the walls of the cages—perhaps a good job since I utterly loathe naturalistic painted backgrounds.

It is clear from contemporary diagrams that the Komodo Dragons were kept in the large enclosures at the southern end of the Reptile House, used, ever since I first went to the Zoo in the 1950s, to house crocodilians. Their glass roofs can be seen in Google Earth—just a short distance away from the new housing for Komodo Dragons.

This Google Earth View of the Reptile House shows the windows
above the cages where the Komodo Dragons were housed. Vita
glass was installed originally. Has it survived?
The new enclosure covered in plastic is the current housing
for Komodo Dragons

It is easy to criticise—ninety years after it opened—aspects of the Reptile House. The compartments for large snakes seem of the wrong proportions, for example. The domestic architect but President of RIBA, Guy (later Sir) Dawber (1861-1938), who took Joan Procter’s very detailed plans, made them buildable and added the external features seems to have missed a few tricks. The sides, especially the western elevation which forms one side of the alley between the equally depressing edge of the Mappin Terraces, are devoid of life. Guillery suggests the outward-facing cage on the eastern side (which often used to house interesting chelonians and is the only relief from the drabness) was inserted later. Dawber also designed—again from a detailed layout by Joan Procter and Chalmers Mitchell—the exterior of the nearby main entrance to the Zoo in the same Italianate style used by earlier architects. I sometimes wonder if Dawber took umbrage at the minor role he was accorded by the Chalmers Mitchell publicity machine; he did not attend the opening of the Reptile House.

But Joan Procter’s house was clearly a great leap forward for the Zoo. But there was still much to learn since reptiles and amphibians died in large numbers after importation. Even the best conditions will not reverse the effects of the stress of capture, storage in unsuitable accommodation and then long sea journeys at temperatures below the optimum together with under- and/or mal-nutrition. Real advances, other than air transport, in how to keep reptiles, other than the ‘easy’ species, would not come for another four or five decades.

I can't resist showing one of my photographs of these wild Komodo Dragons
taken in 2016


*These Komodo Dragons in New York seem to have been forgotten by historians. Their arrival in USA is usually given as 1934, Washington.

Guillery P. 1993. The Buildings of London Zoo. London: Royal Commission on the Historical Monuments of England.

Peaker M. 1969. Some aspects of the thermal requirements of reptiles in captivity. International Zoo Yearbook 9, 3-8. Zoological Society of London. London: Academic Press. 

Procter JB. 1928. On a living Komodo dragon Varanus komodoensis Ouwens, exhibited at the Scientific Meeting, 23 October 1928. Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1928, 1017–1019.

Thursday, 1 November 2018

What to do with unproductive scientists. John Postgate’s solution from the 1980s

Assortative sitting was the name of the game. I soon discovered there was nothing quite so deadly as attending a meeting of Directors of Institutes and Units of the Agricultural Research Council (ARC) (which morphed first by adding Food to its name (AFRC) and then into appallingly-named Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC)). The first trick was to sit somewhere near the back. The second was not to sit opposite certain gentlemen whose facial expressions could induce an uncontrollable laughing fit. The third was to sit next to somebody of like mind so that you could mutter comments heavily laden with sarcasm to one another through clenched teeth. On several occasions I was both skilful enough and lucky to land next to the late John Postgate FRS who was Director of the ARC’s Nitrogen Fixation Unit.

With a father, Raymond, who founded The Good Food Guide and a brother, Oliver, who wrote, produced and appeared in the classic children’s television programmes Bagpuss and Clangers John Postgate was part of a well-known family in the second half of the 20th Century.

One topic which all Directors agreed on was what to do about those scientists who became unproductive, usually in middle age. Some went on churning the same old handle of unexciting research, others slowed down completely. In the research institutes and universities it was virtually impossible to get rid of anybody other than by a quiet word in their ear suggesting they might find more satisfaction elsewhere. If they did not take the hint, you were stuck with them. Because most of those involved had reached a certain grade in the institutes, Principal Scientific Officer, the problem became known as what to do about the clapped-out PSO. Sub-committees were set up and reported but very little happened until a financial crisis led, in England and Wales, to redundancies and the careful inclusion of the ‘clapped-out’ in an area of research to be cut—a very nasty and unfair process.

In our mutterings on the back row, John Postgate and I had very similar views. Scientists would be given a long but fixed term contract until, say, the age of 45 or a fixed time after completing their PhD. If they could then be promoted on merit they would be retained for another, say 10 year contract; if not they would be given long notice (2-3 years) that their contract would not be renewed and provided assistance in fitting themselves for employment elsewhere. Again those staying on would be subjected to a final ‘up or out’ promotion assessment.

The system we suggested would have been similar in a number of ways to that operating in the armed services to ensure the flow of young recruits into the system while retaining the highly capable scientists in the system. I had quite forgotten until I read John’s Biographical Memoir that he had published his proposed system after he retired, based on the army analogue, in a 1991 issue in New Scientist:

There is an old adage to the effect that scientists run out of steam in middle life. One would like to deny its truth, but regrettably it has substance. Most working scientists (among whom I include technologists) are familiar with the older researcher or teacher who has lost momentum. Typically he or she shows low motivation towards keeping up to date with background knowledge, a resistance to solving new problems, a reluctance to adopt new techniques and approaches.
     Scientists such as these are content to coast along as before, painting the odd lily, often quite effectively, and not getting in anyone’s way.These characteristics tend to appear early on if the science has a substantial mathematical or physical component. Sadly, scientists whose output has become lower than it ought to be in quality (not necessarily in quantity) are,on the whole, more prevalent among older age groups.
     Before I am accused of rampant ageism (by the way, I am immensely old myself), let me amplify that ‘on the whole’ proviso. Of course there is that invaluable minority of scientists who do not run out of steam with age; those who, appropriately talented and dedicated, sustain momentum and remain acknowledged leaders in their fields to a ripe old age, setting an example to everyone and achieving well-deserved rewards and honours. There are also a few young scientists who lack steam from the outset; equally there are a few late developers. But in all, the exceptions represent a very small percentage of our scientific workforce.
     In the expansive years of the third quarter of the century, institutes or departments could carry coasters along by group momentum, but those days are over for good. Even if science funding in Britain were to rise to match the norm among other developed countries, the heady days of 1950s-type expansion will not return. Today such people are a source of anxiety to scientific directors and departmental heads, because they are numerous in both the R and D sides of R&D. They unwittingly deny opportunities to young and innovative scientists, to the detriment both of their establishments’ programmes and of the country’s scientific and technical progress.
     Yet as our society becomes ever more science-based, we need an expanding scientific workforce, and it must be one capable of seeing, exploiting and developing innovations almost as soon as they appear. And we need to retain all the innovators we can get, be they old or young.
     How to do this? For reasons which stem as much from specialisation as from age, retraining and redeployment are not the answer: they rarely work among scientists, as Britain’s research councils have so painfully learnt.
     The military solved an analogous problem well over a century ago. Soldiers are recruited to fight and, above a certain mean age, they cease to be useful for that purpose. Therefore they are recruited for a fixed term only and then retired, usually with promotion and a reasonable, if modest, pension. A few who show special talents in appropriate directions are retained for non-combatant duties, but most professional military personnel return to civilian life in early middle age, to make second careers or to relax, as the case may be.
     The careers of scientists ought to follow a similar course. It would be greatly to the advantage of all concerned if they, like the military, were normally taken on for a career-length term, say 25 years, with something like the present civil service pay and promotion prospects. At age 45 they would, subject to performance, normally be promoted by one grade and retired immediately on half pay.
     A minority who retained their usefulness might or might not be promoted, but they would be invited to continue in their posts and pursue their careers normally for another decade. Then another screening would take place. A few outstanding scientists would come through the second screening and work for yet another decade; quite exceptional ones would come through again and again, and carry on well past our present cut-off age of 60 to 65.
     Professional scientists’ contracts would have to be long-term. A succession of short-term contracts would be a disaster – as today’s postdoc trap has shown. The cost of pensions for scientists leaving ought to be balanced out by lower salaries for the young scientists who fill their posts. In effect, however, a career prospect based on single long-term contracts, exceptionally renewable, would render the whole scientific work-force more alert and productive, would ease promotion of young high-fliers, and would avoid the premature rejection of outstanding achievers.
     Being the rule, early retirement would be no stigma, and it would provide society with a reserve of talent, intellectually disciplined and far from elderly, for all sorts of useful purposes – in new employment (helping with the shortage of science teachers, for example), self-employment or, if wealthy enough, in voluntary work.
     After all, the microchip revolution is on the way to making lifelong employment the exception rather than the rule in most walks of life, if only because the alternative is lifelong unemployment for too many of us. Career scientists would, as usual, simply be pointing the way ahead.
Letters followed supporting the Postgate plan but, sadly, the ensuing and  increasingly complex employment legislation prevented the adoption of any such humane scheme—and the ‘postdoc trap’ has been well and truly fallen into. But let’s not go down that road in this post and leave on the the note that John Postgate was one of the good guys. It is also worth noting that he kept lizards, fish and small mammals in his younger days, the first requirement for a biologist to fall into that category.

Postgate J. 1991. Bring in the long-service commission – Science should follow the army’s example. New Scientist 129, 65-66.
Robson R, Smith B, Dixon R. 2016. John Raymond Postgate FIBiol 24 June 1922-22 October 2014. Biographical Memoirs of Fellows of the Royal Society 62, 485-504.

Wednesday, 31 October 2018

Gouldian Finches and Guillemots. H.N. 'Mick' Southern

Sometimes when you are reading up on a subject a surprise awaits. You find that somebody you associate with another field has published in the field you have become interested in. One such recent case was my post on recent research that pinpoints the genetic difference in head colour of the Gouldian Finch. I did not know that the ecologist H.N. ‘Mick’ Southern had worked on that problem but there it was, a paper in the Journal of Genetics in 1945, Polymorphism in Poephila gouldiae Gould. I then learned from his obituaries that he was interested in polymorphism in birds, especially that in the Common Guillemot (Uria aalge) where the ‘bridled’ morph exists alongside the ‘normal’ morph but in increasing frequency the further north in the geographical range of this species.

Henry Neville Southern (1908-1986) was a member of Charles Elton’s Bureau of Animal Population at Oxford. He graduated twice, first in classics, then after a spell in publishing in zoology. As an undergraduate the first time round he had a book published on bird photography. An ecologist who was claimed by the ornithologists as one of their own and by mammalogists as of their tribe he was particularly well known for his long-term studies on wood-mice and on one of their major predators, the Tawny Owl. He edited and wrote a great deal of The Handbook of British Mammals published in 1964 by Blackwells.


Never having moved in ecological or Oxford zoology circles (‘a place best avoided’ was the advice of my PhD supervisor) I did meet ‘Mick’ Southern once. He, John Perry and I were at an old Zoological Club dinner in the 1970s. ‘Mick’ and John were wartime colleagues at the Bureau of Animal Population, when the emphasis was on the control of mammalian (rats, mice, rabbits) and avian (Wood Pigeon, House Sparrow, Rook) pests which were endangering British food supplies and the crews of additional ships needed to bring food by sea through U-boat infested waters.

Photographs of Bridled and 'Ordinary' Common Guillemots

Embed from Getty Images Embed from Getty Images

and the red-headed morph of the Gouldian Finch

Embed from Getty Images

Friday, 26 October 2018

The Kimberley, Australia: A Robert Mertens Day

In the early 1960s, the name Robert Mertens (1894-1975) was well-known to anybody in Britain keen on reptiles because the translation of his book, The World of Amphibians and Reptiles*, hit the bookshops and libraries in 1960. The publication of books on reptiles and amphibians was a pretty unusual event and it joined the other popular survey by Schmidt † and Inger. Living Reptiles of the World, published in 1957 but taking a very different approach.

These books though were expensive. Mertens sold for £3-3s-0d. The equivalent price today is £63 if calculated on the increase in retail prices, £136 if calculated on the increase in pay. I had Schmidt and Inger (the same price) but had to make do with Mertens renewed countless times from the local library. As a result I did not have a copy until I bought one for a few pence several years ago.

Mertens, although a museum man through and through, kept a large collection of animals at work and at home. His survey included what was known of behaviour, ecology and physiology rather than just a review of the kinds of living animals and their taxonomy.

Robert Mertens
from
Contributions to the History of Herpetology
Gradually, I found other work that Mertens had done, for example, on the European lizards and his checklist of European reptiles. I also heard of how he died (see later). However, only when I read the biography in Contributions to the History of Herpetology, did I become fully aware of his work.

In brief, Mertens was born in Russia to German parents—his father was a fur trader. Because of the social unrest that eventually exploded as the Russian Revolution he went to a German university, Leipzig to study medicine and biology. He served a short time in the German army and then joined the Senckenberg Museum in Frankfurt in 1919 where he stayed for the until his retirement in 1960. From 1947, he was Director of the Museum. From 1930 he was also a professor at the University of Frankfurt.

During the Second World War, he spread the collection around Germany and operated a scheme to receive specimens collected by keen soldiers by using the army’s field post system. Imagine the scene on either side of the front line in North Africa as German herpetologists studied and collected the fauna while British and Commonwealth herpetologists, like John Cloudsley-Thompson (1921-2013) of the 7th Armoured Division (Desert Rats), beavered away on the other.

On the Mitchell Plateau in the Kimberley of Western Australia, Mertens is commemorated geographically as well as zoologically. This is because he travelled, collected and explored  extensively in tropical regions including northern Australia and the Indonesian islands. In May, as we walked to Mitchell Falls we passed Little Mertens Falls, waded across the top of Big Mertens Falls and some us saw (I just got the end of the tail) Mertens’s Water Monitor (Varanus mertensi). The newly-described monitor was named in Mertens’s honour by Ludwig Glauert in 1951 (more on Glauert of the Western Australian Museum, Sheffield born and a Sheffield graduate in another post). The naming was highly appropriate—Mertens was the world expert on varanid lizards.

Arrow shows the location of Mertens Falls

Little Mertens Falls
From the cave behind Little Mertens Falls
Big Mertens Falls

Embed from Getty Images
Merten's Water Monitor above Little Mertens Falls


Beyond finding that the two sets of water falls on the Mitchell Plateau were named for him, I have been able to find nothing on when this was done nor by whom it was done. Those who walk or are flown by helicopter over his falls to the Mitchell Falls have no idea who Mertens was or of his role as one of the leading herpetologists of the 20th Century.

There is very little information on Robert Mertens in English and I do not know when he travelled in the northern part of Western Australia. From a list of some of his publications, I would assume the 1920s or 30s. What is known is his sad end. He had kept for a long time a rear-fanged vine or twig snake. When I read about this at the time it was Kirtland’s Vine Snake (Thelotornis kirtlandii) and that identification still appears in some publications including Manson's Tropical Diseases. More recently it is shown as T. capensis from further south in Africa. Whatever the species, it bit him on 5 August 1975. Mertens was 90. No antivenin had been made for this species and eighteen painful days later he died. Throughout that period he kept a diary and ended it with the famous line, ‘a singularly appropriate end for a herpetologist’.

†Karl Patterson Schmidt (1890-1957) of the Field Museum in Chicago, and with similar wide interests to Mertens, died as a result from the bite of another African rear-fanged snake, the Boomslang, Dispholidus typus, in 1957. A single fang of a small specimen caught him and after declining any treatment recorded its effects on him. He died the next day.

*The book first appeared as La Vie des Amphibiens et Reptiles in 1959 with the English, Italian and Spanish editions following. There seems to have been no publication in German. One of the reasons why it was so good is that it was translated into English by Hampton Wildman Parker (1897-1968), retired Keeper of Zoology at the Natural History Museum in London and before that, head of herpetology.

Anon. Mertens, Robert (1894-1975). 2014. In, Contributions to the History of Herpetology, Volume 1, revised and expanded. Edited by Kraig Adler, pp 98-99. (Contributions to Herpetology 30, Society for the Study of Amphibians and Reptiles).

Glauert L 1951. A New Varanus from East Kimberley, Varanus mertensi sp.n. Western Australian Naturalist 3 (1, July 20, 1951), 14-16.

Mertens R. 1960. The World of Amphibians and Reptiles. London: Harrap.

Schmidt KP, Inger RF. 1957. Living Reptiles of the World. London: Hamish Hamilton.